The Torch of Love

 "The Torch of Love or the Tinder of Discord: Cole Turner and the Fracture of the Three Magicians

Before Cole Turner entered their lives, the Three Magicians, despite their disagreements, were an unbreakable unity. Their strength came not only from the spells in the Book of Shadows, but also from the invisible but strong bond of sisterhood. However, Phoebe's love for Cole became a harsh test, exposing hidden cracks and pushing their relationship to the brink of collapse.

Phoebe - The Rebel Heart Bets on Faith
Phoebe has always been someone who lives and acts from her heart. She is someone who seeks adventure, romance, and a love that can define her. Love with Cole is the answer to all those desires. He not only loves her, but also seems to understand her, accepting her rebellious and vulnerable sides.
So “Phoebe’s heart” becomes a shield against all doubt. Every warning from Prue is not a concern, but a judgment—a judgment on her ability to see people, a judgment on her love. She feels she must protect Cole at all costs, because protecting him is protecting her choice, protecting her belief that love has the power to save, that she can see goodness where others see only darkness. Phoebe is not just in love with a man; she is in love with an idea, an ideal, and she is willing to bet her relationship with her sister on that gamble."